"It CAN'T be Toby, can it?!"
We didn't want Spencer to get any closer to that body on the ground!
3. Mounting hysteria
"Please don't be Toby, please don't be Toby, please don't be Toby..."
The body on the ground shared Toby's tattoo, but we refused to believe that it was him!
When we finally admitted to ourselves that the body on the ground was Toby's, our worlds came crumbling down.
6. Sheer panic
WHAT WOULD PLL EVEN BE LIKE WITHOUT TOBY???????
Who would DO this?
"Is just me or is the whole world spinning?"
9. Utter pain...
10. And devastation
We had JUST about gotten over these feelings, but then we saw Toby's motionless body in the summer finale and they all came rushing back!!!!! WHYYYYYYYYYYYY?????????
Did you experience any of these feelings when you thought Toby had died in Season 3?
Let us know in the comments below!