8 Feelings We Had When Toby Returned To Rosewood In Episode 45, 'Eye Of The Beholder'

We were so conflicted!


1. Joy

Pretty Little Liars - 8 Feelings We Had When Toby Returned To Rosewood In Episode 45, 'Eye Of The Beholder' - 1001

"Yay! Toby's back and he's looking super hot!"

2. Worry

Pretty Little Liars - 8 Feelings We Had When Toby Returned To Rosewood In Episode 45, 'Eye Of The Beholder' - 1002

"Okay, so that look wasn't exactly friendly..."

3. Sadness

Pretty Little Liars - 8 Feelings We Had When Toby Returned To Rosewood In Episode 45, 'Eye Of The Beholder' - 1003

"Oh, we guess he's not in the forgiving mood then."

4. Confusion

Pretty Little Liars - 8 Feelings We Had When Toby Returned To Rosewood In Episode 45, 'Eye Of The Beholder' - 1004

"He could never turn Spencer in for 'The Jenna Thing', right?!"

5. Suspicion

Pretty Little Liars - 8 Feelings We Had When Toby Returned To Rosewood In Episode 45, 'Eye Of The Beholder' - 1005

"Why is he suddenly being all brother of the year to Jenna anyway? Does he not remember how she treated him?!"

6. Frustration

Pretty Little Liars - 8 Feelings We Had When Toby Returned To Rosewood In Episode 45, 'Eye Of The Beholder' - 1006

"Seriously, what is going on with him?! Is he really on Jenna's side now?"

7. Love

Pretty Little Liars - 8 Feelings We Had When Toby Returned To Rosewood In Episode 45, 'Eye Of The Beholder' - 1007

"Despite everything, Toby was still there for Jenna when she needed him. He's got such a good heart ❤"

8. Hope

Pretty Little Liars - 8 Feelings We Had When Toby Returned To Rosewood In Episode 45, 'Eye Of The Beholder' - 1008

"Maybe he hasn't completely stopped loving Spencer??"

What did you think was going on with Toby when he returned to Rosewood?

Tell us in the comments below.

Follow Pretty Little Liars: