OMG! Mary Drake Had A Second Child! But Who Could It Be?!

Let's take a look at some of the options!


Noel Kahn

Pretty Little Liars - OMG! Mary Drake Had A Second Child! But Who Could It Be?! - 1001

Not much is known about Noel Kahn's family. We know he has a brother and that's about it! The fact that Noel has returned to Rosewood just as the Liars are discovering more about Mary Drake's past can't just be a coincidence, can it? Either way, Noel definitely has some secrets that need spilling!

Aria Montgomery

Pretty Little Liars - OMG! Mary Drake Had A Second Child! But Who Could It Be?! - 1002

We know Aria's family really well so it would be a major surprise if she turned out to be adopted or swapped at birth! Although this is kind of a long shot, the fact that Aria's folder was the only one taken from Jessica DiLaurentis' hideout by A.D. is pretty suspicious!

Sara Harvey

Pretty Little Liars - OMG! Mary Drake Had A Second Child! But Who Could It Be?! - 1003

Almost everything about Sara Harvey remains a mystery to the Liars, so if she was Mary's secret child it maybe wouldn't be that surprising. But, now that Sara's dead will we ever get any answers about who she was and why she was really in Rosewood?

Jenna Marshall

Pretty Little Liars - OMG! Mary Drake Had A Second Child! But Who Could It Be?! - 1004

Jenna became Toby's stepsister when her mother married Toby's dad, but we don't really know anything about Jenna's parents. Jenna and Mary definitely share some characteristics like dark hair and a badass attitude! But is Jenna really Mary's long lost child?

Alison DiLaurentis

Pretty Little Liars - OMG! Mary Drake Had A Second Child! But Who Could It Be?! - 1005

While Alison may seem like the most likely person to be Mary Drake's child because of their already close connection, this would mean Jessica had always lied to Alison and that Charlotte was in fact her full biological sister. Surely Alison has been through enough without having a bombshell like this dropped on her too?!

Spencer Hastings

Pretty Little Liars - OMG! Mary Drake Had A Second Child! But Who Could It Be?! - 1006

Like Aria, we know a lot about Spencer's family and it seems unlikely that she could be Mary's lost daughter. And yet, Mary and Spencer have shared a few conversations during which their similarities seemed clear. Mary has commented on her history with the Hastings family, could this be what she was referring to?

Bethany Young

Pretty Little Liars - OMG! Mary Drake Had A Second Child! But Who Could It Be?! - 1007

Like Sara, Bethany Young is still kind of a mystery, but her connection to Radley and Charlotte may lead her to Mary Drake. We also know that a woman took Bethany horse riding and asked Bethany to call her 'Aunt Jessie.' Could this have been Jessica DiLaurentis getting to know her niece?

Who do you think could be Mary's secret second child?

Who did you vote for? Do you have any other theories? Let us know in the comments!

And don't forget to tune in to Freeform at 8/7c on Tuesday nights for all new Pretty Little Liars!

Follow Pretty Little Liars: