Remember Jason's Return In Season 2? We All Thought He Was Behind Alison's Murder!

And again, we were wrong...


In Season 2, The Liars were so surprised to find that Jason had moved back into the DiLaurentis House.

Pretty Little Liars - Remember Jason's Return In Season 2? We All Thought He Was Behind Alison's Murder! - 1001

What was he doing back in Rosewood?

They were even more shocked to see Jason throwing out all the things people had left as a tribute to Alison when she disappeared.

Pretty Little Liars - Remember Jason's Return In Season 2? We All Thought He Was Behind Alison's Murder! - 1002

The people who used to live in the DiLaurentis house hadn't the heart to throw everything out, but Jason - her own brother - did? That just didn't make any sense!

The next day, Jason grilled Spencer about Ian's confession.

Pretty Little Liars - Remember Jason's Return In Season 2? We All Thought He Was Behind Alison's Murder! - 1003

We knew Alison's brother would be understandably interested in Alison's killer, but Jason's questioning seemed really intense!

And after her chat with Jason, Spencer remembered a time when Jason was extremely angry with Alison.

Pretty Little Liars - Remember Jason's Return In Season 2? We All Thought He Was Behind Alison's Murder! - 1004

Alison had taken something from his room and Jason seemed to REALLY overreact. What was going on between the DiLaurentis siblings?

Later on in the episode, the Liars saw that Jason had been doing some digging.

Pretty Little Liars - Remember Jason's Return In Season 2? We All Thought He Was Behind Alison's Murder! - 1005

And at that point in the show, uncovered earth was starting to make us a little nervous!

Jason told the Liars that he was putting up a fence for privacy.

Pretty Little Liars - Remember Jason's Return In Season 2? We All Thought He Was Behind Alison's Murder! - 1006

He wanted people to mind their own business.

The Liars wondered who Jason was trying to keep out... or in.

Pretty Little Liars - Remember Jason's Return In Season 2? We All Thought He Was Behind Alison's Murder! - 1007

Was it Ian? Did they BOTH have something to do with Alison's murder? We totally thought they did!

It was a bit different when Jason made his return in Season 7!

Pretty Little Liars - Remember Jason's Return In Season 2? We All Thought He Was Behind Alison's Murder! - 1009

This time round, HE was the one pointing fingers!

He ordered Mary Drake to leave.

Pretty Little Liars - Remember Jason's Return In Season 2? We All Thought He Was Behind Alison's Murder! - 1010

Which we were left feeling a little conflicted about...

He just couldn't understand why Alison was letting her stay when she had helped Elliott!

Pretty Little Liars - Remember Jason's Return In Season 2? We All Thought He Was Behind Alison's Murder! - 1011

We guess he had a valid point.

Alison tried to tell him that Elliott had tricked Mary Drake like he'd tricked her...

Pretty Little Liars - Remember Jason's Return In Season 2? We All Thought He Was Behind Alison's Murder! - 1012

But Jason was having none of it -- and we weren't really sure where we stood!

Were you totally on Jason's side? Or do you think he should have let Mary Drake stay with them?

Let us know in the comments below!

Follow Pretty Little Liars: