1. When we found out that Melissa had been faking her pregnancy.
She'd been faking it since the day after she saw Ian's dead body!
2. When we found out that Ezra had a son.
Although we later found out that Malcolm was not actually Ezra's son. PLL sure knows how to toy with our emotions!
3. When we found out that Nate was Maya's murderer.
That sneaky guy fooled us all!
4. When we saw Garrett's very dead body.
Yikes, this is still giving us the creeps. Poor Aria!
5. When we found out that Toby had joined the A-Team.
We had NEVER felt so betrayed.
6. When Mona returned to Rosewood High.
We had pretty mixed feelings about this -- it was great to see her back, but was it safe?
7. When Meredith knocked Aria unconscious.
Another reason to totally despise that woman.
8. When Wesley kissed Aria.
*jaw drops in SHOCK HORROR*
9. When we thought Toby had died.
NOOOOO!!!!!!!!! We were angry with him for joining the A-Team, but we didn't want THAT to happen.
10. When it turned out that Alison was Red Coat.
We KNEW she was alive!