1. We thought Alison had caught him spying on her and the other Liars.
He could have been stalking them long before Alison disappeared.
2. He seemed super shifty at school.
Was there a reason he didn't really speak to anyone?
3. His tattoo was of the date that Alison disappeared.
We thought this DEFINITELY meant he had something to do with Alison's disappearance!
4. The police found a bloody sweater in Toby's possession.
It was the same sweater that Alison was wearing in the video of the night she disappeared! He was officially wanted for Alison's murder.
5. He said this to Emily:
And we totally thought it meant he regretted killing Alison!
6. And the way he tried to tell her his "big secret" was super creepy!
This was such a terrifying moment!
7. Then Hanna stole Toby's file from the psychiatrist's office...
And we learned that his big secret was that he had had a sexual relationship with Jenna!
8. And like the Liars, we definitely thought he had killed Alison because she had known about their relationship!
Did you totally think Toby was 'A' in Season 1?
Let us know in the comments below!