We Would Be Totally Heartbroken If Caleb Were A.D.

Here's Why...


In Season 7 Episode 17 of Pretty Little Liars, the ultimate #Haleb dream came true when Caleb told Hanna he wanted to marry her. However, many fans think he could be A.D. After all, he is a computer genius with the skills needed to develop the game. What do you think? Vote for the person you think is A.D. using the PLL Suspect Tracker, brought to you by SIMPLE Mobile, and see why we would all be heartbroken if Caleb were A.D. below.

He's always seemed like a dream boyfriend.

Pretty Little Liars - We Would Be Totally Heartbroken If Caleb Were A.D. - 1002

When it comes to #boyfriendgoals, Caleb has always nailed them. Remember when he surprised Hanna at the masquerade ball and when he spectacularly turned down her wicked step-sister, Kate? In both of these moments and more, Caleb made us fall a little bit in love with him. Our image of him as the model boyfriend would be completely shattered if we found out he were A.D.

It would destroy our dreams of a Haleb wedding.

Pretty Little Liars - We Would Be Totally Heartbroken If Caleb Were A.D. - 1003

If Caleb were A.D. that would make his engagement to Hanna a total sham. Did he only propose to keep anyone from suspecting him? We just can't believe he would be so cruel.

And it would be completely devastating for Hanna.

Pretty Little Liars - We Would Be Totally Heartbroken If Caleb Were A.D. - 1004

We've seen Hanna struggle after her breakup with Caleb in the past, so we can only imagine how hard it would be if this theory were true. And it would be terrible to watch her go through the wedding planning process only to discover her fiancé is A.D.

In fact, it would feel like a massive betrayal for all the Liars.

Pretty Little Liars - We Would Be Totally Heartbroken If Caleb Were A.D. - 1005

Caleb has helped the group on countless occasions in the past, so they would be totally caught off guard if he turned out to be their enemy. But why would he help them beat the game if he was actually using it to hurt them? He was poisoned while trying to stop it. Unless that was a cover up too?

And it would break up his bromance with Toby.

Pretty Little Liars - We Would Be Totally Heartbroken If Caleb Were A.D. - 1006

Remember how great it was when they first teamed up to clear Ashley's name after she was accused of killing Wilden? And it was Caleb who was there for Toby when Yvonne died. Is their friendship just another lie? Perhaps it was a way for Caleb to get insider intel from the police -- if you were A.D. it would definitely be handy to have a cop in your corner. If this were true, we'd gladly watch Toby punch him again.

We would have to question everything we know about him.

Pretty Little Liars - We Would Be Totally Heartbroken If Caleb Were A.D. - 1007

The Caleb we know is smart, funny, and loving. So why would he create this terrible game? Does he have some connection to Charlotte we don't know about? We never found out who hired him in New York. He told Hanna he couldn't even tell her the name of the company -- maybe it was the Carissimi Group? Perhaps they corrupted him while he was working there? But we just can't believe he is capable of switching from dedicated boyfriend to evil manipulator – we just can't.

Catch up on the latest episodes of Pretty Little Liars Season 7B here on Freeform.

And tell us if you have any theories on why Caleb could be A.D. in the comments.

Follow Pretty Little Liars: