14 Times Amy Terrified Us In Episode 9 We hid behind a pillow every time she was on screen. 1. When she got super freaky with her knuckle cracking. THE NOIIIISSSEEE! We can't bear it! 2. When her innocent eyes quickly turned into the most evil of eyes. 3. The sound of her screaming while being forced to drink the pure water. 4. Any time her eyes turned pitch black. 5. When she spread her legs and seduced Alex in Russian. 6. THIS head tilt! 7. When she told them that they were all going to die... And we seriously believed her. 8. When she tried to tear Garrett's ear off with her teeth! 9. And then casually spat out his blood. 10. When she threw Alex across the room with nothing but her eyes. 11. When we realized that she intentionally killed her best friend just to come to Camp Stillwater! 12. When she really held a grudge against Krissy. 13. When we realized she had been behind all of the murders throughout the summer! 14. When she responded to Jessie so innocently while drenched head to toe in blood! What has you the most terrified about Amy? Tell us in the comments below.