1. A person wearing the satanic cult mask appeared at Deb's masquerade ball in 1970!
2. The novel that spawned Deb and Keith's nickname for each other.
3. The beautiful message Keith wrote in the novel for Deb in 1970.
4. Alex's perfect marshmallow roasting stick.
5. Deb petitioning for the Children's Defense League.
6. Keith on the cover of this poetry magazine!
7. The case file code left in Garrett's father's cuff link.
Does HOL stand for Holyoke?
8. One of Keith's many beautifully written post cards to Deb!
9. These groovy earrings that Deb is totally rocking.
10. Deb's engagement ring!
Not sure if we can trust this Fred guy... #DeithForLife!
11. What does Alex think you can bake with ginger and chicken blood?!
12. The worrying look on Keith's face when he told Deb that "I really need this".
13. Amy's haunting white eyes!
14. The satanic pentagram that Jessie drew marks five different points on Camp Stillwater's map!
15. Keith's map that leads right to their buried time capsule.
16. Drew giving Blair peanut butter cups like Cricket used to do!
17. The skull and deer heart that Garrett and Jessie found!
18. Blotter's severed head buried on top of Cricket's time capsule.