1. Joel had an older brother named Michael!
2. The counselors are all still suspicious of Deb!
3. The camp night out is a Camp Stillwater tradition!
4. One of the campers has asthma.
5. The Tall Man wants Joel to kill Amy!
6. Jessie is jealous of Amy and Deputy Syke's relationship.
7. Joel's older brother killed himself on the night of his prom!
8. Joel started seeing the Tall Man before he got to camp!
9. Alex actually does like Cricket!
10. The Tall Man says someone else will die if Joel doesn't get rid of Amy!
11. Drew doesn't want to give Blair another chance.
12. The camera doesn't work for Joel anymore!
13. Joel's brother saw the Tall Man too before he died!
14. Deb did not hook up with Joel the night of the Masquerade Ball!
15. Deputy Sykes' father was investigating Camp Stillwater before he died!
16. Joel accidentally beat up his friend at prom because of the Tall Man!
17. The Tall Man is Holyoke!
18. Anton can see Holyoke too!
19. Alex had a plan to woo Cricket under the blood moon!
20. A mysterious masked person pushed Cricket into a bear trap!
Which moment from Episode 5 shocked you the most?
Tell us in the comments!