5. When Alison was attacked by A.D.
We knew something bad was coming when Alison asked that policeman into her house.
But we were powerless to do anything!
And that sinister message he left seriously gave us the creeps!
We totally thought Archer was back from the dead!
Poor Alison was seriously shaken up after the attack.
Thank goodness Spencer and Hanna were close by!
4. When Hanna was captured and tortured by A.D.
She was kept in an old shack in the middle of the woods.
The perfect creepy location -- far enough away that no one would hear her scream.
We thought it was horrendous enough when she was tortured with the hose...
But the cattle prod was worse than anything we could have imagined!
Remember when Hanna spots it in Episode 3 and has that terrible flashback?
We had terrible flashbacks too!
3. When a hooded figure locked the Liars in Spencer's car.
Everything about this moment was INTENSE!
We totally had our eyes closed.
The threatening message!
Were they close to finding out A.D.'s identity?!
And, of course, the fact that their attacker was right outside.
2. When the Liars struck Archer with their car.
We did not see THAT coming!
We were already super tense because Alison was on the run...
Which set us up for the BIGGEST scare when the Liars ran into Archer!
We knew it couldn't be good by the looks on the Liars' faces...
And sure enough, this sight haunted our dreams for days.
Actually, it's STILL haunting our dreams!
1. When everyone thought Hanna was dead.
Seriously, we're STILL not over this one!
The gang knew something was wrong when they got that message from A.D...
And running into the church, they found Hanna hanging from the bell tower!
Remember how heartbroken Caleb looked?!
When they brought her down, we were beginning to believe she was really dead...
But then it turned out to be just another one of A.D.'s dolls!
We were never so happy to see one!